High Deer Populations May Benefit Crawly Critters

As reported by: Jessica Marshall, Discovery News

Oct. 24, 2008 -- Growing populations of deer are often blamed for damaging forest habitats by overgrazing on tender plants. But new research suggests that they may be helping certain forest critters, including salamanders, snakes and invertebrates like slugs and ground-dwelling insects.

Researchers found fewer numbers of crawlies in areas where deer were excluded than where they roamed. It was not what they were expecting.

"We were really surprised by the direction of the relationship," said Katherine Greenwald of Ohio State University in Columbus, who led the study, published in the Journal of Wildlife Management.

"I would have expected that, especially, the gastropods [snails and slugs] and salamanders would have had the opposite response to deer grazing," agreed Otso Suominen, of Finland's University of Turku, who was not involved in the study.

White-tailed deer populations have expanded in recent years in the eastern United States. Deer thrive along the edges of forests, and there are more and more edges as forests become increasingly fragmented. With top predators like wolves and cougars largely absent, there is little to keep populations in check.

Earlier studies have shown that deer have negative effects on vulnerable plants.

"The impact is almost always that they're completely wiped out where there are these high deer densities," Greenwald said.

Other work found that mammals and birds also suffer from high deer populations.

So, why did the new study show the opposite? One possibility is that high deer populations enrich the soil with their droppings, creating a cascading effect where insects and other invertebrates multiply in richer soil, attracting salamanders, which attract snakes.

Suominen's work in Finland has shown that reindeer grazing on tree saplings can enhance soil moisture. A similar effect could be at play here, he said.

But, the study is preliminary, Greenwald cautions, and there may be other explanations.

"I'm hesitant to say, 'Deer are great for salamanders,'" Greenwald said.

The salamanders that she observed in the study are red-backed salamanders, which are hardy and pretty abundant. "It could be that the species that are sensitive to grazing just aren't there anymore."

It may also be that in heavily grazed areas, there are fewer places for salamanders, snakes and invertebrates to hide, so they prefer to lurk under the planks Greenwald placed in the plots to count the critters underneath. In areas without deer, these planks may see less use because they are only one of many places to hide, creating the artificial impression that there are fewer animals around.

Still, the findings may have implications for managing deer populations. "There are a lot of initiatives to reduce deer numbers and I think that overall that's probably a good thing, when you consider the impact on ecosystems as a whole and the lack of predators," Greenwald said. Nonetheles, her study shows "there could be some unpredictable responses."

Suominen points out that this type of study compares high deer populations with no deer.

"One cannot predict using this kind of setup what would be the impact of reduced deer density," he said.

"What is considered overabundance depends largely on our own human perspective and varies a lot at each situation," he adds. "However, in many cases, some intermediate herbivore density would be optimal."

The Wildlife Society

PARC: Partners in Amphibian and Reptile Conservation

Joining the blog revolution

Hi! My name is Kelly and here is my story:

It all began in the year 1979. My parents met in their native country of Holland and immigrated to Atlanta, Georgia in hopes of pursuing the American dream. Three years later I was born and the world has never been the same since...

I grew up in Marietta, Georgia during the 1980s and 1990s. A budding biologist from the very beginning, my life in the 1980s was filled with poor fashion choices and trips into the neighborhood woods in search of interesting flora and fauna. I often came home to impress Mom with buckets full of tadpoles, dragonfly larvae, caterpillars, salamanders, green anoles, little brown snakes, and the occasional turtle. The 1990s were dedicated to reading mass quantities of books from the local library; traveling to the motherland (Holland); playing soccer throughout the eastern United States; figuring out ways to con Mom into adopting more rescued dogs and cats into the family; and playing dress-up/writing plays with my little brother, David.

In order to build on my fascination with the natural world, I attended the University of Georgia and graduated with a degree in Wildlife Ecology in 2006. Throughout college, I worked as a naturalist at the Chattahoochee Nature Center, a research assistant in the Wetland Ecology lab at UGA, a lab assistant in the Urban Entomology lab at UGA, and a Wildlife Ecology Lab intern at the Joseph Jones Ecological Research Center in Newton, Georgia. Upon graduation I immediately landed a job as an ecologist with Greenhorne and O'Mara, an engineering consulting firm.

After two years in a corporate setting, I decided that I wanted to branch out and find a place where I would be able to better utilize my ecological knowledge, interpersonal talents, and passion for educating others. I found that place at Cochran Mill Nature Center and am ecstatic about taking on all the joyous challenges that are associated with being the new Environmental Education Coordinator.

In my spare time I love reading, sewing, painting, drawing, herping, knitting, dancing, biking, kayaking, cooking, writing, and spending time with loved ones. I also absolutely adore animals. I have two rescue dogs, Osmo and Mazzy; a cat, EAOP-ie; a rabbit, Elliott; and an outgoing tortoise, Pyxis. My favorite scents include lavender and vanilla.

My ultimate dream is to one day be as fabulous a creature as my dog, Mazzy, who volunteers her time as a therapy animal and goes to work with my mom weekly to spend time with mentally disabled adults.

On February 25, 2006 my brother David was killed in a pedestrian hit-and-run in Marietta, GA. After making it through two of the most difficult years of my life it is time to continue moving forward. I am so grateful for my mother, my friends, my incredible furry family members, yarn, nature, sewing machine, and books; because without the love, encouragement, laughter, licks, and challenges from these people, "daemons", and inanimate objects, I seriously doubt that I would be alive today.

I decided to start this blog as a way to catalog completed projects, ecological resources, read books, sources of inspiration, news articles, and random crap for myself, my friends, and my relatives (both in the United States and in Holland). I am thoroughly excited to begin this new year of healing (both emotionally and physically) and I can't wait to see what new things I learn and what new people I meet!